Indiana Flow plumbing and water purification logo
Indiana Flow technician standing beside a stainless steel three-compartment kitchen sink with a pre-rinse sprayer he plumbed

Indiana Flow Blog

What Not to Put Down a Garbage Disposal This Thanksgiving

By Indiana Flow  ·  November 13, 2026

Knowing what not to put down a garbage disposal saves you from the busiest clog of the year: the sink after a holiday meal. Indiana Flow is a family-owned plumbing company run by Omar and Ahmad Saltagi, licensed in Indiana under PC12000053, and reachable at 317-463-3569. Here are the foods that jam a disposal, the ones that clog the drain behind it, and how to reset a stuck unit safely.

The Short Answer

Keep grease, potato peels, bones, fibrous vegetables, coffee grounds, rice, pasta and eggshells out of your garbage disposal. Indiana Flow, a family-owned plumbing company in Indianapolis, Indiana, sees these foods behind most jammed disposals and clogged kitchen drains after holiday meals. Scrape them into the trash or compost, then run only small, soft scraps with cold water.

Foods That Jam the Grinder or Clog the Drain

A disposal does not have blades. A spinning plate with two small impellers throws food against a grinding ring, and the slurry then travels through your trap and drain line. Some foods stop the grinder; others get through and cause trouble farther down the pipe.

  • Grease, oil and fat: liquid when hot, it hardens as it cools and coats the drain line. Pour it into a can and throw it out once it sets.
  • Potato peels: the starch turns into a thick paste that glues itself to the grinding ring and the trap.
  • Rice, pasta and bread: these keep absorbing water after they go down, then swell into a sticky plug.
  • Celery, onion skins, asparagus and corn husks: long fibers wrap around the impellers and stall the motor.
  • Bones, fruit pits and shells: too hard to grind, they chip the grinding ring and strain the motor.
  • Coffee grounds and eggshells: both settle in the trap as a dense sediment. The idea that eggshells sharpen the blades is a myth, since there are no blades to sharpen.

Why Holiday Cooking Is Hard on Kitchen Drains

A Thanksgiving kitchen produces almost every item on that list in one afternoon: turkey fat, potato peels, celery ends, stuffing bread and bones. It tends to go down one sink within an hour, often with hot water that keeps the grease liquid until it reaches colder pipe and sets.

Grease builds up in layers, which is why a sink that drained fine on Thursday can back up the following week. In older Indianapolis homes, that buildup can reach the main line. If several drains are slow at once, our guide to sewer line warning signs explains what that pattern usually means.

What Is Safe to Run Through It

A disposal is built for small amounts of soft scraps that slip off plates during cleanup: bits of cooked vegetables, soft fruit and leftover sauce. Scrape plates into the trash first and treat the disposal as the cleanup step.

Run cold water before, during and for several seconds after grinding. Cold water keeps fat solid so it gets chopped and flushed instead of smearing along the pipe. Feed scraps in gradually and let the motor clear before adding more.

How to Reset a Jammed Garbage Disposal

If the unit hums but will not spin, or stops completely, a jam or a tripped overload is the usual cause. Most homeowners can clear it safely with these steps:

  • Step 1, cut the power: turn off the wall switch and unplug the unit under the sink, or switch off its breaker. Never put your hand inside the disposal.
  • Step 2, free the plate: insert a hex key into the socket on the bottom center of the unit and work it back and forth until the plate turns freely.
  • Step 3, remove the object: use tongs or pliers, not fingers, to pull out whatever caused the jam.
  • Step 4, press reset: wait a few minutes for the motor to cool, then push the red reset button on the bottom of the unit. It is a thermal overload switch.
  • Step 5, test with cold water: restore power, run cold water, and switch it on.

Signs It Needs a Plumber Instead

A reset fixes a simple jam, not a worn-out unit or a clog behind it. Call a professional when the reset button keeps tripping, when the motor hums but never turns even though the plate spins freely by hand, or when water drips from the bottom of the unit. A leak at the sink flange or drain connection can often be repaired, but water seeping from the housing means the shell has cracked and the unit needs replacement.

A quality disposal typically lasts 8 to 15 years, and past about 10 years, replacement is usually better value than repeated repairs. If the disposal runs but the sink still drains slowly, the clog is past the unit, and drain cleaning and repair is the right fix. Grease that reaches the street is covered in who is responsible for the sewer line.

How Indiana Flow Handles Disposal Repairs

Indiana Flow offers garbage disposal repair and installation across Indianapolis and Hamilton County. We clear jams, test motors, fix leaking connections and replace units past saving. A new disposal needs an electrical outlet under the sink; if there is none, an electrician must add it before we connect the unit.

You get instant online Good, Better and Best pricing, itemized and in writing, with no callback needed. Every job carries a 1-year labor warranty, 0% financing is available through Wisetack and Klarna, and we are open Monday through Friday, 8am to 5pm. Our plumbers serving Indianapolis and Hamilton County also cover Carmel, Fishers, Westfield, Noblesville, Zionsville and McCordsville.

The Bottom Line

Keep grease, peels, starches, fibrous scraps, bones and grounds out of the disposal, use cold water, and reset a jam with the power off. If the unit keeps tripping, leaks or the sink stays slow after the holiday, call Indiana Flow at 317-463-3569 or request an instant quote online.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you put potato peels down a garbage disposal?

No, potato peels should go in the trash or compost. Their starch turns into a thick paste that sticks to the grinding ring and the drain trap, and large batches of peels are one of the most common causes of jammed disposals after holiday meals.

Is it OK to pour grease down the disposal if I run hot water?

No, hot water only moves grease farther down the pipe before it cools and hardens. Let grease set in a can or jar, throw it in the trash, and run cold water when you use the disposal.

Do eggshells sharpen garbage disposal blades?

No, garbage disposals do not have blades, so there is nothing to sharpen. They use impellers that throw food against a grinding ring, and eggshell fragments tend to settle in the trap as sediment.

How do you reset a garbage disposal?

Turn off and unplug the disposal, free the plate with a hex key in the socket on the bottom, remove the jammed object with tongs, then press the red reset button on the bottom of the unit. Restore power and test it with cold water running.

Why does my garbage disposal hum but not spin?

A humming disposal that will not spin is usually jammed by a hard object or a wad of fibrous food. If the plate turns freely with a hex key and the motor still only hums, the motor is likely failing and the unit may need replacement.

How long does a garbage disposal last?

A quality garbage disposal typically lasts 8 to 15 years with proper use. Smaller units wear out faster in busy kitchens, and once a disposal passes about 10 years, replacement usually costs less over time than repeated repairs.

Free Estimate

Ready to Talk to a Plumber?

Indiana Flow serves Indianapolis and all of Hamilton County with upfront pricing, same-week scheduling, and 0% financing on qualifying work.

Call 317-IND-FLOW(317) 463-3569